What have fifty years of freedom meant for the poor of India? Is India destined to remain the land of poverty?
By sheer numbers alone, the history of India’s poor is India's history and this history is compellingly recorded in In the Land of Poverty.
An unforgettable oral history of an impoverished Indian family, In the Land of Poverty draws readers into an understanding not just of the personal experience of poverty but of the intractable reasons for its continuance.
On 15 August 1947, the day of India‘s independence from Britain, Ram Dass Pasi and his family were ‘Untouchables’ – lowest of the low in an apparently unchanging caste system, landless serfs bonded to a feudal village lord in a remote part of Uttar Pradesh deep in the heartland of India. Fifty years later as the country celebrated its half-century of independence, Ram Dass‘s family still suffered poverty and oppression – this despite their efforts and despite the changes which have transformed the face of independent India.
This book is their story – and the story of modern India. Told through the voices of several generations, In the Land of Poverty takes the reader on a journey into the reality of South Asian poverty – the powerlessness, the sickness, the illiteracy and all the other deprivations which enmesh the poor. Gradually we learn to understand not simply the human reality of what it means to be poor, but also the central paradox of modern India: half a century of democracy, economic growth and constitutional commitment to social justice has not lessened the acute, mass poverty of the country.
Published as Words Like Freedom: The Memoirs of an Impoverished Indian Family, 1947-1997 by HarperCollins in India, 1998.
A sequel and second edition will be published in 2016.
HarperCollins | Zed Books
Purchase a copy
Read an excerpt
Related articles by Siddharth Dube:
Lessons from a poor little VIP constituency - The Indian Express
The failure to expand irrigation — and to preserve the abundance of existing tanks and local canals — is to blame. Equally to blame is the utter neglect of efforts to modernise agriculture through diversifying crops, boosting yields, or storage and marketing.
The poor little VVIP constituencies - The Indian Express
If all that has been attempted in Amethi and even Andipatti is not enough, what more is needed to ensure progress in reducing poverty and other deprivations across rural India, asks Siddharth Dube.
Incredible India - The dark reality - International Herald Tribune
The government's latest survey of living standards reports that the number of extremely poor Indians, those chronically unable to consume even the minimum calories needed for full functioning, is an astonishing 301 million, just 19 million less than in 1983. At this rate, it would take India 300 years to lift all its people out of even the most extreme levels of poverty.
Exploiting Poverty; Bleak Forecast for India - The Times of India
INDIA will enter the next millennium with the largest mass of deeply impoverished people of any country, some 350-500 million persons. This is an extraordinary human tragedy given the scale, intensity and life-long length of their suffering. But even more tragic is the certainty that a half-century or even a century later, India will still remain the land of mass poverty.
India's Tragic Destiny - The Washington Post
once hauntingly described India's poor as "this naked, hungry mass."
Despite a half-century of democracy, steady economic growth and
constitutional commitment to welfare goals, India's poor are still
naked and hungry.
Prince, Apprentice - Outlook
According to Siddharth Dube’s remarkable documentation of the problems of the region, the absence of radical land reforms, despite Congress’ tall claims of having abolished the zamindari system in the area, means that the poor have not only remained poor but their status might worsen in the years to come unless there’s substantial investment in agriculture, infrastructure and the social sector.
Telling it like it is - The Telegraph
A silent revolution brought on by a little known book written in English is sweeping through a small village located in the heartland of caste-ridden Uttar Pradesh.
In Their Own Words
The dull rain of tragedy
THE TIMES LIERARY SUPPLEMENT
On the Famished Road
The Great Betrayal : Indian Land Reforms
A life without land
Why do the Poor Remain Poor?
Land Reform in India
DEVELOPMENT AND COOPERATION
“A penetrating study.”
STEPHEN P. COHEN, Senior Fellow, Brookings Institution, author of ‘India: Emerging Power’
"Elegantly intertwining the story of one poor family in Uttar Pradesh with the larger history of post-colonial India, this book documents the tragic consequences of the Congress Party's failure to undertake serious land redistribution and other social reforms. It is essential reading for anyone who wants to understand the perpetuation of poverty and inequality in the world's second largest country."
BETSY HARTMANN, co-author 'A Quiet Violence', author 'Reproductive Rights and Wrongs' and Director of the Population and Development Program, Hampshire College
"Academically grounded, yet immensely readable, it brings to life the experience of those whose story has hitherto been swallowed up in that dark allusive term 'the masses'...makes all the recent, highly praised novels on India look contrived and artificial."
JEREMY SEABROOK, author of 'In the Cities of the South'.
“Sharp, convincing and absolutely to the point…for his ability to explain [the need for equity] in clear, human terms to contemporary readers whose perspectives on poverty has been addled by talk of modernisation, ‘trickle down’ economic reform and the overweening importance of population control, Dube deserves the widest possible commendation."
SUSAN RAM in Frontline.
"An important book that serves as a powerful antidote to much of the euphoria generated these days about the benefits of economic liberalisation. It deserves to be very widely read."
DARRYL D'MONTE in Humanscape
"A skilful melding of oral testimony and explanatory text...important reading."
PAMELA PHILIPOSE in the Indian Express
“A consciousness-raising book…told with a passion that emerges not only from the words of three generations of family members themselves, but also from the author’s analysis of the broader political economy.”
PRABHU GHATE in the Economic and Political Weekly
"(Written) with such skill that it holds the reader's interest all the time."
K.F. RUSTAMJI, Padma Vibhushan, The Hindu
"Siddharth Dube’s argument is relentless, like the poverty he describes."
ARUNDHATI ROY, author of the Booker Prize winning novel The God of Small Things
“Excellent thick description…well grounded in history…a fascinating collection of anecdotes and insights from rural India.”
CONTEMPORARY SOUTH ASIA
“We seldom take the time to appreciate the dramatic impact historical events have on individual lives and Dube’s book gives us the opportunity to do so.”
JOURNAL OF THIRD WORLD STUDIES
"Subaltern history at its best."
"Not just the story of one family but the story of the masses of the Indian people."
"Compelling...The voices of the poor are urgent, sombre, stoic and pensive…they heckle you as you turn every page."
THE TIMES OF INDIA
“As finely written as a first-rate work of fiction.”
"Every Indian ought to read Siddharth Dube's book."
"Brings alive the ugliness of poverty...an excellent narrative."
"Surely recovers the voices of the poor."
INDIAN REVIEW OF BOOKS
"Incisive analysis. Written with powerful clarity."
“An intensely readable and memorable account.”
DARRYL D'MONTE in Tehelka.com
"A carefully crafted journey...far more powerful than any other pure socio-political or economic analysis."
"An excellent book...stands distinctly apart from other such writings not only because of its simplicity of style, but also because of the enormous empathy and compassion (it) evokes."
Biography of a poor dalit family